Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 54:16 — 49.7MB)
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Amazon Music | Podcast Index | RSS
Episode 458 | Is It the Market… or Your Process? (How to Diagnose a Slowdown + Create Momentum for September)
Podcast Description
If your school feels a little more sparse right now—fewer leads, more no-shows, more “we need to think about it,” more tire-kickers—you’re not crazy, and you’re definitely not alone.
In Episode 458 of School Owner Talk, Duane and Allie dig into a question a lot of owners are quietly asking: Is this slowdown the market… or is it our process? Instead of panic-changing everything (prices, scripts, ads, branding), they walk through a calm, practical way to diagnose what’s actually happening.
The big idea is simple: if you don’t know which number is down, you’ll fix the wrong thing. So they break it into three truth-telling metrics—lead volume, show rate, and close rate—and then shift into what to do next, including show-up systems, follow-up, and grassroots momentum plays that can help you win September.
They also talk about the seasonality factor (end of summer + back-to-school) and why this time of year usually brings better results—more routine, more structure, and families looking for positive activities—while still acknowledging that commitment can feel lower than it used to.
Key Takeaways
1) Don’t panic-change everything—diagnose first
When things feel slow, it’s tempting to make big emotional moves: drop prices, rewrite your sales script, overhaul your website, rebrand, or crank ad spend without a plan.
However, changing five things at once makes it impossible to know what actually worked. Duane’s reminder is to stay steady: diagnose → adjust → execute.
2) The three numbers that tell the truth
Duane and Allie recommend tracking three core metrics consistently:
- Lead volume (by source): How many leads you’re getting, and where they’re coming from (Facebook/Instagram, Google, referrals, walk-ins, events, etc.).
- Show rate (booked → showed): How many people schedule, and how many actually walk through the door.
- Close rate (showed → enrolled): Of the people who show up, how many enroll.
If leads are down, your solution is different than if show rate is down. And if close rate is stable but leads and show rate are down, you don’t need to “sell harder”—you need better lead quality and stronger show-up systems.
3) Track lead volume by source, not as one big bucket
It’s not enough to say, “Leads are down.” You want to know which leads are down.
Allie shares how tracking every call and lead source helped her identify what worked, what didn’t, and where to stop wasting money. Duane adds that if you know your numbers, you can make smarter decisions about ad spend because you understand what it costs to acquire a student versus the lifetime value of that student.
4) Show rate is often the hidden problem
No-shows create the illusion of activity—your calendar looks full, but enrollments don’t match.
They call out common reasons show rate drops:
- Low-commitment leads
- Unclear expectations
- Weak confirmation process
- Families shopping multiple options
Allie shares real numbers from her month to illustrate how quickly no-shows can pile up, even when leads are coming in.
5) Be consistent in how you define and track “trial” vs “booked intro”
Duane points out a common tracking issue: some systems mark someone as “on a trial” the moment they book.
He prefers separating:
- Booked intro (scheduled)
- Trial (they actually showed)
The key isn’t which definition you choose—it’s being consistent so your measurements mean something over time.
6) Seasonality matters—but so does the current behavior shift
They acknowledge the reality:
- Summer can be “weird” for martial arts schools (vacations, inconsistent attendance, freezes).
- Back-to-school usually helps because families want routine and structure again.
At the same time, they’re seeing a broader behavior shift:
- Attention is fragmented
- Skepticism is up
- Commitment is down
- Free trials can attract “free shoppers” (the old Groupon effect)
7) Personal contact still beats automation when it comes to show-ups
Automations help, but Duane strongly recommends a real phone call to confirm appointments and pre-frame expectations.
He also recommends a concerned, human follow-up when someone no-shows, with a clear reschedule option and focused follow-up over the next 24–48 hours.
8) Grassroots momentum can fill the gaps when things feel sparse
They recommend leaning into practical, local plays—especially going into September:
- Reactivation campaigns for former students and past leads
- School partnerships (speeches, after-school programs, daycare/school outreach)
- Flyer delivery and local grassroots marketing (done intentionally)
- Cross-promotions with local businesses
Action Steps for School Owners
Step 1: Start a simple weekly scoreboard
Track these three numbers every week:
- Lead volume by source
- Show rate (booked → showed)
- Close rate (showed → enrolled)
Don’t overreact to one weird week. Look for trends over a month, a quarter, and a year.
Step 2: Fix show rate before you obsess over closing
If you’re seeing more no-shows and tire-kickers, tighten your show-up system:
- Add a real phone call confirmation (even if most don’t answer)
- Pre-frame the appointment (what to wear, what to expect, who will greet them)
- Make the experience feel personal and relational from the first contact
Step 3: Create a 24–48 hour no-show follow-up plan
When someone no-shows:
- Call with a concerned tone (“Hope everything’s okay”)
- Offer two specific reschedule options
- Follow up consistently over the next 24–48 hours
Step 4: Run a September momentum plan (pick 2)
Choose two grassroots plays and run them hard for 7 days:
- Reactivation campaign (former students + past leads)
- School outreach / after-school partnerships
- Local business cross-promotions
- A structured “excitement program” for National Martial Arts Appreciation Month
Step 5: Don’t change five things at once
Make one change, measure the result, then adjust. That’s how you build a system you can trust.
Additional Resources Mentioned
- Episode 455 (National Martial Arts Appreciation Month game plan + downloadable PDF)
- Stephen Oliver: Six Simple Steps to Add 100 New Students to Your School (book referenced)
- Mentioned concept: fast lead response time (calling quickly after a lead comes in)
